Ok, answering to both Weezi and Ensorcelled Minds.
Search engines care about both Title and Description, though Title is more important and is Always used, as Description is sometimes passed over and not always displayed in Search Results page. However, both are important for page optimization and should be filled with relevant Keywords.
If you have same titles for two different products and start your product descriptions with the same message, Google might label your pages “duplicate” and drop one of them from replacement results completely.
Think why you've posted them as two products and not as one with quantity equals two. There has to be something unique about each of them. So use that as a Keyword to differentiate 2 products.
You should always choose the most relevant and descriptive keywords for each product page. Think about phrases that your customers would use when they replacement for your products. Don’t always try to use generic Keywords that are very popular.
Using one of Weezi's products #page has been deleted# try to describe it. What kind of keywords / key phrases you'd use? Things like "Apron", "Retro Apron", "Vintage Inspired Apron" or "Cherry Apron" come to mind.
Let’s say “Cherry Apron” term has only 480 Global Monthly Search Queries a month, which doesn’t seem like much compared to more generic terms like “Apron” or even “Vintage Apron”. But see how competitive those terms are.
By optimizing your page for “Cherry Apron”, you'll get top ranking on Google for this term. This means almost all 480 people replacementing for “Cherry Apron” every month will be yours. Not only that they will click on your link (as it's at the top of the first page on Google), they will also see exactly what they were replacementing for - An apron with cherries splashed all over it!
So now, do you think 480 highly targeted leads a month is enough? After all, you have only one “Cherry Apron” to sell ... and it looks like they are popular in December. :wink:
By the way swapping "cherries" with "strawberries" in the Title of your second product might help you make those two products look unique, but might not help your second product with high rankings on Google, if nobody is replacementing for "Strawberry Apron". You still need to check what keywords are people using when they replacement, that are most relevant to your product.
Please note - I haven't done a detailed keyword analyses on your page.
I am using your product as an example to prove my point - Relevant Keywords will bring you more Targeted Traffic. And getting less, but targeted traffic is better than a lot of non-targeted!